Our second cocktail is the Phish Hook. Created by Jamie Boudreau in 2010; this is the Simon Difford variant.
Created by Jamie Boudreau in 2010; this is the Simon Difford variant.
Half-fill a mixing jug with ice.
Add all ingredients and stir until well-chilled.
Strain into a coupe glass.
AI generated anecdote for article length
The warm, lazy air of the summer night hung around the backyard as the sun dipped below the horizon. A group of friends gathered around the patio, their voices merging with the chirping of crickets in the background. It was one of those nights where time seemed to stretch, where no one was in a hurry to leave, and the atmosphere hummed with relaxation. In the center of it all was Matt, standing in his kitchen, mentally preparing for what he liked to think of as his 'signature moment' of these summer gatherings. It was time to mix up a batch of his latest cocktail creation, the "Phish Hook."
Matt had always been known as the guy who brought the unexpected to their gatherings, whether it was a strange new board game, a rare bottle of whiskey, or an obscure but amazing record that everyone would fall in love with. Tonight, his surprise would be liquid in nature—a cocktail he had been perfecting for weeks, tweaking it every time until he found the perfect balance of flavors. The Phish Hook was that balance. Made with rye whiskey, elderflower liqueur, Punt e Mes, and maraschino liqueur, it was a drink that felt both rugged and delicate, complex yet approachable.
As he pulled out his tools—a mixing glass, bar spoon, strainer, and a coupe glass—he could hear his friends chatting and laughing outside, oblivious to the magic he was about to stir up inside. The bar cart was stocked, bottles neatly arranged. Matt’s eyes moved over the selection with satisfaction. He grabbed the bottle of rye whiskey first, appreciating its earthy, spicy aroma. He poured a healthy measure into the mixing glass, watching the amber liquid settle in the bottom, catching the dim light of the kitchen.
Next came the elderflower liqueur. Its floral sweetness was the element of surprise in the Phish Hook, cutting through the boldness of the rye and adding a light, fragrant touch. A small splash joined the whiskey, the smell of elderflowers faint but unmistakable. Then came the Punt e Mes, a deep, rich Italian vermouth with bittersweet notes that gave the drink its depth. Matt added a healthy splash of the vermouth, watching as it mingled with the other ingredients.
Finally, the maraschino liqueur. Sweet, with a hint of tartness, the maraschino brought it all together, softening the rye and balancing the bitterness of the Punt e Mes. Just a small dash was enough—it was the secret ingredient that, when added just right, made the Phish Hook stand out from any other rye-based cocktail.
With all the ingredients in the glass, Matt reached for the long, slender bar spoon and began to stir. He loved this part—the quiet clinking of ice against glass, the smooth rhythm of his hand turning the spoon. There was something meditative about it, the way the cold gradually seeped into the mixture, blending the flavors without shaking them into a frenzy. The patience of stirring, the discipline it required, always made Matt feel like a real craftsman. After what felt like the perfect amount of time, he grabbed his strainer and poured the golden liquid into the waiting coupe glass.
The Phish Hook had a delicate golden hue with a faint amber glow, sitting perfectly in the coupe. Matt admired it for a second, appreciating the layers of flavors that were waiting to be discovered. He took a quick sip to confirm that everything was balanced just right—smooth, with the spice of rye upfront, followed by the floral elderflower and bittersweet Punt e Mes, rounded off by the subtle cherry undertones of the maraschino. It was exactly what he had envisioned.
He carefully carried the coupe glass outside to where his friends sat, deep in conversation. "Alright, folks," Matt announced, holding the glass up like a trophy. "I’ve got something special for you tonight—this is what I’m calling the Phish Hook."
His friends turned to look at him, curiosity piqued. He passed the glass around for everyone to try, watching their faces closely for reactions. The first friend to take a sip raised his eyebrows in surprise, then smiled. "Wow, Matt, this is incredible. It’s got that kick from the rye, but it’s so smooth… and is that elderflower? Man, this is good."
Encouraged by the positive reaction, Matt handed out more coupe glasses, filling each one with the carefully crafted cocktail. As his friends passed them around, he could see that same look of pleasant surprise on their faces—an expression that told him he had nailed it. The Phish Hook was an instant hit.
As the night wore on, the drinks flowed, conversations deepened, and laughter filled the air. The Phish Hook seemed to have an almost magnetic pull, drawing everyone in and keeping them lingering just a little longer. With each sip, Matt’s friends kept asking him how he had come up with the drink, complimenting the intricate balance of flavors. He could only grin and shrug, playing it off like it had been no big deal, but deep down, he knew he had created something special.
By the time the last coupe was drained, Matt could tell that the Phish Hook had made its mark. It wasn’t just a drink—it had become part of the night’s memory, forever tied to that warm, perfect summer evening under the stars. He knew his friends would be asking for it at every gathering from here on out, and that was just fine with him. After all, it wasn’t every day you got to reel in a catch like the Phish Hook.
Ingredients
Directions
Half-fill a mixing jug with ice.
Add all ingredients and stir until well-chilled.
Strain into a coupe glass.