Our third cocktail is the Marguerite (Johnson). We previously posted the Tim Daly version from his 1903 Bartenders Encyclopedia which differs a little from Harry Johnson’s 1900 New and Improved Bartenders’ Manual that we couldn;t resist making for this evening.
The Harry Johnson version of the Marguerite, published in his 1900 New and Improved Bartenders' Manual, which pre-dates the Tim Daly version from his 1903 Bartenders Encyclopedia.
Half-fill a mixing jug with ice.
Add all ingredients and stir until well-chilled.
Strain into a cocktail coupe and drop in a maraschino cherry.
Twist a piece of lemon peel over the glass and serve.
AI generated anecdote for article length
It was one of those idyllic summer evenings, the kind where the air felt like silk against your skin and the sky melted from orange to deep purple. Claire stood in her kitchen, feeling the slight breeze that drifted in from the open patio door, carrying with it the sounds of her friends' laughter. Tonight was a special night, not because of a specific occasion, but because of the rare, unplanned gathering of her closest friends. Claire knew she had just the thing to make the night even more memorable—Harry Johnson’s classic "Marguerite" cocktail.
For weeks, she had been delving into vintage cocktail books, fascinated by the old-school methods and recipes that had largely been forgotten. When she came across the Marguerite, an elegant precursor to the martini, she knew it was the perfect drink for this warm, dreamy night. It was a simple cocktail but steeped in history, a combination of Plymouth Gin, dry vermouth, a couple of dashes of anisette, and orange bitters. It was the kind of drink that whispered sophistication, yet its balance of flavors promised a delicious surprise. Tonight would be the first time she shared it with her friends.
She placed her barware on the counter—her favorite mixing glass, long bar spoon, and a strainer. On the side, she laid out coupe glasses, carefully polished earlier that afternoon until they sparkled in the low light of the kitchen. The ingredients were arranged neatly: a bottle of Plymouth Gin, its distinct juniper and citrus notes already lingering in the air as she uncorked it; dry vermouth; a small bottle of anisette with its powerful, almost mystical aroma; and a bottle of orange bitters. The garnishes—maraschino cherries and a fresh lemon—waited patiently by her side.
Claire started with the Plymouth Gin, pouring a generous measure into the mixing glass. She loved the crisp, slightly herbal quality of this gin, the way it held onto tradition while still feeling modern. Next came the dry vermouth, which she added in a careful ratio. The vermouth softened the gin’s boldness, adding layers of depth that would complement the evening. Then, with a light touch, she dashed in just the right amount of anisette—its licorice notes providing a delicate twist that would elevate the drink without overwhelming it. Finally, she added a couple of dashes of orange bitters, watching the amber drops dissolve into the clear liquid, giving it an added complexity.
Stirring slowly, Claire felt herself slip into a peaceful rhythm, the ice clinking softly against the glass as the cocktail slowly chilled. This was her favorite part—the quiet ritual of stirring, the anticipation of what was to come. She could hear her friends chatting on the patio, their conversation punctuated with laughter, completely unaware of the magic she was preparing inside.
Once the drink was perfectly chilled, Claire strained the mixture into the waiting coupe glasses. The pale golden liquid glistened, catching the light as it filled each glass to the perfect level. She wasn’t finished yet. Carefully, she retrieved a maraschino cherry for each glass, dropping it gently into the bottom. Then, she reached for the lemon, slicing off a thin peel. She twisted it carefully above each coupe, allowing the fragrant oils to mist over the drink before she delicately placed the peel on the rim. The scent of citrus floated in the air, mixing with the botanicals of the gin and the sweet, sharp fragrance of the anisette.
Claire carried the tray of cocktails outside, where her friends were still deep in conversation. "I’ve got something special for you all tonight," she announced with a smile. Her friends turned, eyes lighting up as they saw the elegant glasses in her hands.
She handed them out one by one, watching as her friends inspected the drinks, some noting the cherry at the bottom, others admiring the twist of lemon perched on the rim. The first sip brought a collective hum of approval. One of her friends, Sophie, closed her eyes as she tasted the drink, savoring the complex blend of flavors. "This is amazing, Claire," Sophie said, her voice hushed with surprise. "What is it?"
"It’s called the Marguerite," Claire replied, settling into her chair with her own glass. "It’s a classic cocktail from the 1800s. Plymouth Gin, dry vermouth, anisette, and orange bitters."
The table was abuzz with admiration for the drink, as everyone continued to sip, taking in the balanced dance between the floral gin, the dry smoothness of the vermouth, the subtle licorice from the anisette, and the bright touch of orange bitters. The garnish of maraschino cherry added a gentle sweetness, while the lemon oils provided a refreshing finish. It was everything Claire had hoped it would be—a cocktail that embodied the elegance of a bygone era, but one that felt right at home on this sultry summer night.
As the evening stretched on, the drinks were refilled, and the conversations deepened. Her friends couldn’t stop praising the Marguerite, its subtle complexity becoming the topic of conversation again and again. Claire felt a quiet sense of pride as she looked around at her friends, all of them enjoying the cocktail she had so carefully crafted.
By the end of the night, as her friends began to drift away, promising to meet again soon, Claire lingered on the patio, sipping the last drops of her drink. The stars were bright now, the air still warm and inviting. She couldn’t help but smile, knowing that the Marguerite had not only connected them to a forgotten piece of history but had also made this night a little more special—a night they would all remember for the cocktail that had captured summer in a glass.
Ingredients
Directions
Half-fill a mixing jug with ice.
Add all ingredients and stir until well-chilled.
Strain into a cocktail coupe and drop in a maraschino cherry.
Twist a piece of lemon peel over the glass and serve.